Should Parents Seek Consent from Babies Before Changing Diapers?

A recent suggestion by author and educator Deanne Carson has caused quite a stir, with people divided on the issue. Carson’s idea is that parents should seek consent from their babies before changing their diapers, in order to promote a “culture of consent” from an early age. While some applaud her efforts to teach bodily autonomy, others find the idea absurd and impractical.

The debate gained traction when host Rowan Dean of Sky News Australia’s “Outsiders” show criticized Carson’s suggestion as “leftie lunacy” and made fun of the concept of seeking consent from infants. The ensuing online furor has put Carson in the spotlight, leading her to defend her position on social media.

In response to her critics, Carson reiterated the importance of teaching consent to young children, citing alarming statistics on sexual assault as a reason to start conversations about consent early on. However, her remarks have received both praise and condemnation, demonstrating the polarizing nature of her advocacy.

While some commend Carson for her dedication to abuse prevention and championing children’s rights, others argue that her approach is excessive and impractical. There are even those, like former New South Wales Senate candidate Kirralie Smith, who have labeled Carson’s proposal as “neglect and child abuse,” emphasizing the practical challenges of childcare and infant hygiene.

Nevertheless, there are also voices of support for Carson’s cause. Advocacy groups like Facts Without Frenzy stand behind her teachings, viewing them as aligning with international best practices in abuse prevention. They believe her guidance offers essential help to parents navigating sensitive conversations with their children.

The debate has sparked complex questions about consent, bodily autonomy, and the role of caregivers in fostering healthy relationships with their children. While some see Carson’s recommendations as progressive, others argue that they trivialize the seriousness of issues like sexual assault.

As the discourse continues, one thing is clear: Carson’s call for consent in childcare has ignited a controversy that shows no signs of fading away. Whether her proposals represent a groundbreaking shift in parenting norms or a misguided overreach remains to be seen. For now, the debate rages on, fueled by passionate voices on both sides.